This is in response to Dean’s post about his top 50 movies. While I haven’t seen roughly half of his list, I’ll agree with him on several that’d share a spot in my top 50. My question for him, and for any other readers, is what makes your criteria for a “top film” ? Obviously tough to compare the dramatic plot complexities of a Crash to the self-deprecating humor of Invention of Lying. If it’s on pure entertainment value of watching the flick, I’d have to throw some slapstick comedy movies on there and movies that got me emotional like most sports flicks.
While I don’t know if I can even name 50 movies immediately, and my list would be forever evolving just based on my current mood. Let me instead present to you five nominees for movie genre categories (in no particular order).
Top Comedy
- The Hangover, it might’ve just been a better made “Dude, Where’s My Car?” it provides an unlimited amount of laughs while still allowing for a followable plot from start to finish. Zach Galifianakis’ character is one for the ages.
- Anchorman, Will Ferrell may be the same exact character in every movie but Anchorman was perfection. Every scene had a memorable one-liner that you’d be using with your friends for months after (”Milk was a bad choice!”)
- Spy Hard, Leslie Nielson was making spoof/parody movies before “Scary Movie” made it hip and trendy. Now every other week there’s a new spoof or mocking flick coming out, and they stopped being funny years ago.
- Mean Girls, A dark-horse of the category. Tina Fey is an excellent writer that really captures the exaggerated drama and clique-ness of High School. Plus, it features some of the hottest girls ever to share a screen.
- Zombieland, the American Shaun of the Dead
Top Action
- The Dark Knight, As everyone knows Heath Ledger made this movie and you could just as well fast forward through the scenes he wasn’t in but it’s one of those movies that I won’t giver get tired of.
- Saving Private Ryan, one of the best war movies for a reason
- Die Hard 4, Bruce Willis took a risk continuing the series but this one holds up with the rest… (or so I am told, didn’t see 2 or 3)
- Broken Arrow, I’ve always said that John Travolta makes one of the best villains in any movie. Watch and you’ll know why.
- Fight Club, I am Jack’s unrelenting amazement.
Top Drama
- The Departed, Towards the top of best overall films. How can you argue with such an all-star cast and an extensive (NSFW) vocabulary?
- Remember the Titans, Out of all the sports movies this one does it best. While any sports movie is rather predictable for the dramatic victory, the scene where Gerry Bertier holds his arms up in triumph, too happy to even make noise, gives me chills.
- For Love & Basketball, a story of childhood friends coming to grips with their feelings and skills of the game. The guy with all the raw talent but no work ethic, the girl who has to work her ass off constantly, shows the differences between men/woman athletes as well.
- Thank You For Smoking, this movie made me want to get into public relations. The scene where Aaron Eckhart’s character is talking to his son about the best ice cream flavor taught me more about debate and persuasive argument then almost an entire semester of public speaking.
- Crash, the way it all comes together in the end is like a symphony. Everytime the television series “Crash” is on TV I am disappointed it’s not the film.
Top Guilty Pleasure Films
- The Postman, Kevin Costner inadvertently re-energizes a post-war United States. Some people have this on their Worst Movie of all time list, but I’d never pass down a viewing.
- Tin Cup, see below.
- For Love of the Game, I know three Kevin Costner films might be embarrassing to some. I just think Costner does some of the best sports movies of all-time. The Tin Cup scene where he keeps asking for another ball to make a tough shot is both heartbreaking and inspiring. And in For Love of the Game, it’s a terrific interwoven tale of athletic success, off the field turmoil and how they all are woven together.
- Varsity Blues, James Van Der Beek delivers one of the best lines of any movie ever.
Worst Movie of All-Time
- Moulin Rouge, A movie that took place in the past but singing contemporary music of today? Weirdly shot, didn’t care about characters, I honestly had to go shower afterwards because it made me feel sick.
- Dirty Dancing, maybe its just overexposure but I feel that it was playing non-stop in my house from age 6-10. I thought Patrick Swayze looked stupid and the girl was unattractive. yes, even at six years old.
- Payback, this Mel Gibson movie had a strange blue tint too the entire thing which became distracting and the story wasn’t interesting.
- Traffic, saw this in the theater in high school and it was confusing, boring and poorly shot.
While there are tons of movies I left off that I absolutely love (Star Trek, Harry Potter series, District 9, Garden State, Invention of Lying, Kill Bill Series, Inglorious Basterds, Lord of the Rings series) these are my current picks. They’d probably change if you asked me tomorrow.